Economy & Debt

$88.6 billion a year: the silent haemorrhage

Every year, Africa loses almost as much money through illicit financial flows as it receives in aid and foreign investment combined. Who benefits, and how can the tap be turned off?

Africa is often described as a continent that “receives”: aid, loans, investment. Much less is said about the money that leaves it, quietly and illegally. Yet according to UNCTAD (the UN Conference on Trade and Development), these outflows are huge.

$88.6bnleaves Africa every year through illicit financial flows — about 3.7% of the continent’s GDP.

What are we talking about?

Illicit financial flows are money earned, moved or used illegally. They take several forms:

  • Trade misinvoicing: under-declaring the value of exports (minerals, oil, cocoa…) or over-invoicing imports to move foreign currency out. This is the main source.
  • Tax evasion and aggressive tax avoidance by some multinationals, which artificially shift profits to tax havens.
  • Corruption and embezzlement of public funds, the proceeds of which are often stashed abroad.
  • Criminal activities: trafficking, poaching, gold smuggling.

According to UNCTAD, these sums are almost equal to the combined official development assistance (about $48 billion) and foreign direct investment (about $54 billion) the continent received each year over the period studied. In other words, Africa is in many ways a net creditor to the rest of the world.

A shared responsibility

On the African side

  • Under-resourced tax and customs administrations.
  • Corruption among some elites who protect these channels.
  • Opaque mining contracts and excessive exemptions.

On the international side

  • Tax havens and financial centres that take in these funds.
  • International tax rules designed mainly by and for rich countries.
  • Weak cooperation in returning stolen assets.

How to turn off the tap

  • Transparency: public registers of companies’ beneficial owners, publication of extractive contracts.
  • Modern customs: comparing export declarations with partner countries’ import data to spot gaps.
  • Tax cooperation: the African Union and the African Group at the UN are championing a UN framework convention on international tax cooperation, so that African countries help write the rules.
  • Asset recovery: pursuing proceedings to repatriate ill-gotten wealth.

The High-Level Panel chaired by former South African president Thabo Mbeki raised the alarm about the scale of the problem back in 2015. Turning off the tap on illicit flows means finding money for schools and hospitals without borrowing.